Should you invest when markets are at all time highs?
When markets hit all‑time highs, it’s easy to wonder whether you’ve missed your moment, but history shows these milestones are a normal part of long‑term investing. Rather than trying to predict the perfect entry point, staying invested, focusing on your goals, and following a disciplined plan can make a far bigger difference to your financial future.
Should I invest when markets are at all-time highs? It’s a question many people ask, often with equal parts curiosity and concern. When markets reach new peaks, it’s natural to wonder whether you’ve missed the best opportunities or whether a downturn is just around the corner. After all, buying something at its most expensive point can feel counterintuitive.
But when it comes to investing, market milestones rarely tell the full story. In fact, long‑term investors who stay out of the market simply because prices are high often miss significant opportunities for future growth. So, should you invest when markets are at all‑time highs? The answer is more nuanced, and more encouraging, than you might think.
Remember that part of being a long-term investor is accepting that markets will rise and fall. Because of this, returns aren’t guaranteed and you may not always get back the amount you started with.
New highs are more common than you might expect
It’s tempting to view an “all‑time high” as a rare moment, but historically, markets hit new peaks far more regularly than most people realise. That’s because over long periods, global stock markets have tended to rise in line with economic growth, corporate earnings, innovation and productivity gains.
Think of it this way: every long‑term upward trend is made up of a series of new highs. Each one might feel like a tipping point, but for well‑diversified investors with a long time horizon, these moments are a normal and expected part of the journey.
Waiting for markets to “cool off” can therefore be counterproductive. While you’re on the sidelines, markets can continue to climb, and timing your re‑entry becomes even harder.
Market timing sounds appealing, but rarely works in practice
The idea of investing at the perfect moment, just before markets rise and then exiting just before they fall, is understandably appealing. But the reality is more difficult. Short‑term market moves are unpredictable, and even professional investors find it nearly impossible to get timing decisions right consistently.
Missing even a handful of the market’s best days can severely impact long‑term returns. And, interestingly, some of the strongest days of performance often occur close to the weakest ones; typically during periods of volatility when investors are most likely to step away.
Rather than trying to predict what will happen next, taking a long‑term, disciplined approach can help smooth out the emotional ups and downs of investing.
What happens if you only invest at market peaks?
Surprisingly, even if you invested only on days when major equity markets reached record highs, historical data shows that you would still have experienced meaningful long‑term growth. Markets don’t simply rise in straight lines, and there will always be periods of decline after a peak, but over the long run, staying invested tends to work in investors’ favour.
This highlights an important point: the long‑term direction of markets matters far more than the specific day you choose to invest.
The real risk isn’t investing at a high, it's not investing at all
Many people worry about investing at the “wrong time,” but the bigger long‑term risk is delaying an investment strategy altogether. Sitting on large amounts of cash may feel comforting, but over time, inflation may erode its purchasing power. Even modest inflation means that money kept in cash can potentially lose value year after year.
Investing gives your money the potential to outpace inflation and grow over the long term. By staying invested through market cycles, highs and lows alike, you give your wealth the best chance to work for you.
Time in the market beats timing the market
The most important driver of investment growth is time. Time for markets to recover from downturns, time for compound returns to build, and time for your financial plan to take effect.
I often say that successful long term investing is about ‘time in the market,’ not ‘timing the market.’ By keeping your focus on long term objectives rather than short term market noise, you can avoid making emotional decisions that may hinder your financial progress. A well diversified portfolio which is aligned to your goals and risk tolerance is designed to navigate short term volatility and help keep you on course.
Joseph Allen, Senior Investment Specialist
A financial plan helps put market highs into perspective
Investing is not just about markets; it’s about your goals, whatever they may be. Whether you’re saving for retirement, a home purchase, or creating a legacy for your family, a financial plan provides confidence. A plan can also help you understand how and why you’re investing, regardless of what markets are doing on any given day.
A financial adviser can help you:
- build a portfolio that suits your objectives,
- balance risk and opportunity,
- remain disciplined through market changes,
- and stay focused on the bigger picture.
Most importantly, they can help you make decisions based on strategy rather than emotion.
So, should you invest at an all time high?
If you’re investing with a long‑term plan, an all‑time high doesn’t need to be a red flag. Markets will rise and fall many times over your investment journey. What matters most is starting early, staying invested and remaining disciplined.
The right time to invest isn’t determined by market headlines, it’s determined by your goals. If you’d like to talk through your circumstances or explore how investing could support your financial future, our advisers are here to help. Let’s have a conversation about what’s right for you.
There are no hidden fees or charges and you’ll only pay if you choose to go ahead with the recommendations in your personalised financial plan.
Important information
This article is for information purposes only. It is not intended as investment advice.
Any views expressed are our in-house views at the time of publishing. This content may not be used, copied, quoted, circulated or otherwise disclosed (in whole or in part) without our prior written consent.
